By FRANCIS JOSEPH
The abandoned Beetham Water Recycling Plant will have its genesis in the Privy Council soon.
Super Industrial Services Limited (SIS) and Rain Forest Resort Limited have filed an appeal against the judgment of the Court of Appeal dated December 1, 2025, in which National Gas Company (NGC) is claiming more than US $26 million (TT$176 million) in an over payment for the abandoned project.
The appeal was filed on Wednesday morning in the Privy Council’s office in London.
Kiel Taklalsingh and Stefan Ramkissoon represent SIS, while Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj SC, lead the team for Rain Forest resorts.
On December 1, 2025, the Court of Appeal upheld a High Court decision confirming that five asset transfers from SIS to Rain Forest Resorts were done with the intent to defraud the National Gas Company.
In a unanimous decision, Justices of Appeal Prakash Moosai, Charmaine Pemberton and Mira Dean-Armorer dismissed both appeals, and confirmed that four mortgages and one debenture—collectively valued in the hundreds of millions of dollars—were sham transactions designed to place SIS’s assets beyond NGC’s reach.
The dispute arose from the 2014 Beetham Water Recycling Plant project, for which SIS received over US$32 million in mobilisation funds but failed to proceed with the work. The contract was terminated, and NGC sought to recover an over payment of about US$26 million.

THE FACTS
On March 10, 2014, NGC entered into a written contract with SIS for the design and construction of a water recycling plant at Beetham. The parties agreed the contract price would be US $162, 055,319. According to the contract, the commencement date for the works was April 22, 2014 and the completion date was October 22, 2015. On May 8, 2014, NGC made a mobilisation advance of US $32, 411,063.75 to SIS. It was agreed that the Mobilisation payment would be repaid by way of deductions against monies due to SIS under Interim Certificates.
By exchange of letters between SIS and NGC dated the 19th of February 2015 and the 23rd of February 2015 respectively, NGC and SIS agreed that the repayment of the Mobilisation Payment would be postponed and be deducted from Interim Payment Certificates.
On the 20th of November, 2015, NGC served a termination notice on SIS. In their notice of termination they itemised the following grounds of termination:
a. SIS had advised the management of NGC that it had underbid for the works and was unable to continue the works without a review of the Contract Price and the project schedule;
b. SIS had commenced the withdrawal of construction resources, manpower, and equipment from the project sites and was providing only security and protection services for the works.

The notice provided that termination would take effect on December 4, 2015, 14 days from the date of the notice. Accordingly it was not possible for NGC to make the agreed deductions. NGC has claimed over payment to SIS in the amount of US $26, 007,665.00.
In computing this figure, NGC took into account the value of the work done. Parties met with a view to resolving the matter. In November, 2015, NGC commissioned a search of the Companies Registry and discovered four Deeds of Mortgage each dated the 5th of March, 2015.
By these Deeds, SIS transferred its defined property to Rain Forest Resort Ltd. SIS also issued a deed debenture dated November 12, 2015 charging its property to Rain Forest. NGC contended that the mortgages and the debenture were intended to put the assets of SIS beyond the reach of their creditors.
NGC commissioned the services of a private investigator, Benson Harripersad, who conducted investigations on Rain Forest Resort, as the mortgagee and debenture holder cited in the instruments. The search revealed that Rain Forest was a paper company without any assets.
On December 23, 2015 the NGC instituted proceedings against SIS and Rain Forest Resort. NGC sought declarations against SIS and Rain Forest Resort on the ground that the mortgages and the debenture were intended to delay, hinder or defraud the NGC.

The NGC sought further orders that the mortgages and the debenture be set aside and expunged from the Index of Deeds kept by the Registrar General. The claim was heard before Madame Justice Joan Charles in July and September, 2019 and on February, 20, 2020, she delivered her judgment, finding in favour of NGC and granting all the relief sought. In the interim, NGC had instituted arbitration proceedings in which SIS had filed a counterclaim.
LOCAL DECISIONS
In her judgment, Justice Charles identified four issues for her consideration. They were:
(a) Whether the claimant was a creditor of the first defendant at the time of the execution of the conveyances and debenture.
(b) Whether the first defendant conveyed the properties described with the intention to defraud its creditors
(c) Whether as a result of the conveyances the claimant suffered prejudice
(d) Whether the mortgages and the debentures amounted to sham transactions.
In respect of each issue, the judge considered the competing arguments and the relevant evidence. She found in favour of NGC in respect of each issue. She held that NGC was a creditor for the purposes of s.78 (1) of the Act. 6. She referred to the facts in respect of each instrument and held that there was an intention to defraud creditors including NGC.
She held, again by reference to the evidence before her, that NGC suffered prejudice. She also held that the transactions were sham transactions.
On December 1, 2025, the Court of Appeal stated, “we hold that the findings of the trial judge have not been shown to have been plainly wrong. In keeping with the many authorities emanating from the Privy Council, the latest of which is Christo Gift v Keith Rowley, we find no good reason to overturn the decision of the trial judge. The appeal is accordingly dismissed, the orders of the trial judge are affirmed and we invite submissions on the issue of costs.”


