Statement To The Media By Ramesh L. Maharaj S.C. In Respect Of The Decision Given By The Judicial Committee Of The Privy Council
In The Appeals Of Pitilal v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago. Elie v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago and Mohammed v the Attorney General.
Having regard to the public interest which this case has generated, I consider that it is my duty to the media and to the public to explain the judgment given by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (“JCPC”).
l . The JCPC upheld the validity of the decision of the UNC-led government to declare the State of Emergency in 2011 which lasted three and a half months. The JCPC also upheld the validity of the Regulations made by the government pursuant to that State of Emergency, but the JCPC held that two of the Appellants’ constitutional rights were violated by the State and restored the order made by the High Court to award Earli Eli and Dominic Pitilal, the sum of $50,000.00 each.
2. The JCPC in its judgment also gave guidance to Courts in determining decisions made by governments to declare public emergencies based on criminal activities and actions of individuals and groups.
3 The State of Emergency in 2011 was declared following an escalation of murders and a reported plot to assassinate the Prime Minister following drug seizures at the Piarco International Airport. That was the first time that a State of Emergency in Trinidad and
Tobago was declared on the basis of such criminal activities.
- Prior to the 2011 State of Emergency in Trinidad and Tobago, the declaration of a State of Emergency was a rare event. Public emergencies were declared in 1970 and 1971 during a period of intense civil strife and mass mobilization known as the Black Power Revolution and in 1990 when there was an attempted coup against the government by the Jamaat Al Muslimeen.
- The State of Emergency of 2011 therefore marked a new justification in Trinidad and Tobago for the use of emergency powers. After that public emergency ended in Trinidad and Tobago, there were three public emergencies declared on the basis of criminal activities and criminal actions.
- (a) In December, 2024 the PNM-Ied government declared a public emergency in response to criminal gang-related violence involving the use of dangerous firearms which lasted until April, 2025.
- The UNC-led administration on 18 July, 2025 declared a public emergency in order to combat what was described as a coordinated criminal network operating out of prisons in Trinidad and Tobago. That State of Emergency lasted until January, 2026.
- Soon after that State of Emergency ended on 3 March, 2026 the government declared a new public emergency in response to a fresh outbreak of violence between organized criminal gangs which ended in September, 2026.
7 The Appellants’ arguments in respect of the 201 1 State of Emergency included that a State of Emergency should not be declared as a tool for a government to fight crime when the Police Service, the Army and all the institutions of the State were functioning. The Appellants contended that a public emergency ought only to be declared where there is a threat to the life of the nation. The JCPC in its judgment agreed that the threshold for the declaration of a State of Emergency ought to be a threat to the life of the nation but decided that the evidence given by the State before the Court satisfied that threshold. The JCPC also held that the Regulations made pursuant to that declaration of the State of Emergency were reasonably justified and therefore were lawful.
The JCPC made reference to Three Public Emergencies Created in Trinidad and
Tobago 2011
- The judgment given by the JCPC is however of great public importance because they establish the governing principles which Courts would now apply to determine the lawfulness of public emergencies based on the criminal activities and criminal actions of individuals and/or groups. The JCPC in its judgment gave guidance to the Courts in making such decisions.
- The JCPC at paragraph 66 of its judgment referred to the three public emergencies created in Trinidad and Tobago after the 2011 public emergency. The consideration by and the decision of the JCPC in the instant appeal therefore took place against the backdrop that in Trinidad and Tobago the following public emergencies were declared in Trinidad and Tobago:
- On 30 December 2024 the Government declared a public emergency which lasted until April 2025,
- On 1 8 July 2025 another public emergency was declared lasting until January
2026 and
- on 3 March 2026, a public emergency was declared which was lifted on 15
September 2026.
- The JCPC expressly recognized that the appeal had important implications for more recent States of Emergency declared by the government but made no findings as to the validity of those States of Emergency as those were not matters arising for its determination.
11 The JCPC however, interpreted Sections 7 and 8 of the Constitution of Trinidad and Tobago and established principles directly relevant to the validity of the subSequent States of Emergency which raise questions about the continuation and repeated invocation of States of Emergency as a mechanism for crime control.
Governing principles o/ law laid down by the JCPC in Respect or the Validity o/Public
Emergencies Declared in the Country A tier 2011
12. Those governing principles of law established by the JCPC include the following:
- Where the foundation of a Proclamation for a State of Emergency is made under Section 8 (2) (c) of the Constitution of Trinidad and Tobago, the risk to public safety, and the nature and scale of the threat must be extremely serious, sudden and out of the ordinary. Accordingly, Section 8 (2) (c) sets a high threshold for the creation of a public emergency i.e. a threat to the life of the nation (paras 67-77 and 90 of the judgment).
- (a) The JCPC also agreed with the Supreme Court of Jamaica in Campbell v Attorney General of Jamaica [2025] JMFC Full 2, that the concept of a public emergency suggests something likely to be short lived. (para 90).
(b) In the Campbell case, the Supreme Court of Jamaica held that a series of
State of Emergencies declared by the Governor General between January
2018 and February 2023 was unconstitutional. The Crown in that case had relied on the high crime rates in the various areas in which the State of Emergencies had been declared. That case is discussed by the JCPC at paragraphs 73-76 of the JCPC’s Judgment.
111. (a) The JCPC endorsed the importance of the Courts balancing the need to respect the expertise and responsibilities of the government in taking the decision to declare a public emergency with the vital role of the Courts in protecting the Constitutional rights and liberties Of those citizens who find themselves the target of extreme measures adopted by a government.
| 2005) 2 AC 68 |
(b) The JCPC quoted statements made by Lord Hope in A v Home Secretars at paragraphs 92 and 93 of the judgment which stated:
“92. Lord Hope referred to the dangers that lie in store for democracy itself if the courts were to allow individuals to be deprived of their right to liberty indefinitely and without charge on grounds of public interest by the executive.
93. The decisions of the Courts in Campbell, Somare and other cases where courts have considered the validity of public emergency show the judiciary fulfilling this vital role with courage and intellectual rigour.”
(c) There is a distinction between circumstances falling within Section 8 (2) (c) of the Constitution and ordinary criminal activity. The Courts need to be alert to attempts by governments to address problems arising from inadequate resourcing or lax enforcement of the ordinary criminal law by conferring exorbitant powers on the police and security forces. This was emphasized by the JCPC at paragraphs 94 and 95 of its judgment.
iv. The JCPC at paragraph 93 also endorsed certain comments made by Supreme Court of Jamaica in Campbell that restrictions on fundamental rights should be temporary and highlighting the impact of such measures on unpopular minority groups:
“They said that while they accepted that democratic rights may be limited or restricted in order to ensure public safety, and maintain public order, the restrictions should be temporary so that affected rights are impaired as least as is reasonably possible. They highlighted the dangers that such measures pose particularly to unpopular minority groups:
“It is unquestionable that the constitutional rights of members of certain marginalized communities will be disproportionately affected as there is increased policing of such communities. There is likely to be an erosion of public trust in government. There will be negative implications for social and economic stability
CONCLUSION — JCPC’s Decision ought not to be interpreted that the repeated public emergencies declared in the country after 2011 were valid
- The JCPC’s decision ought not to be interpreted as deciding that the repeated declarations of State of Emergencies made since 2024 were valid. The appeals concerning the 201 1 State of Emergency arose from a specific Proclamation made in response to circumstances prevailing at that time including an escalation in gang related murders, and intelligence concerning retaliatory violence following substantial drug seizures as well as a report of conspiracy to assassinate the Prime Minister.
- The frequency and duration of the recent States of Emergency raised additional constitutional questions which are to be considered in light of the principles endorsed by the JCPC in the appeal of Earl Eli and Others which include that a State of Emergency should be short lived, the restrictions on fundamental rights must be temporary (not indefinite) and ought not to be used to address problems arising from ongoing problems of inadequate resourcing or lax enforcement of the ordinary criminal law. Those are matters which require the State to enforce existing laws and effectively administer policies.
- Similarly, a finding that the 2011 Regulations were lawful does not establish that the Regulations made under the subsequent States of Emergencies were valid. Regulations made under the subsequent States of Emergencies will be judged by asking whether they are reasonably justified by the circumstances which existed at the time.
Dated: 17th November, 2026
Ramesh L Maharaj


